A festival to remember a riot? New York event stirs debate

FILE - In this Aug. 19, 2002 file photo, Carmel Cato, center, reaches out to embrace Norman Rosenbaum, right, as they walk together in a show of unity into a New York restaurant on the 11th anniversary of the 1991 Crown Heights riots sparked by the deaths of Cato's seven year old son Gavin Cato and the murder of Rosenbaum's brother Yankel, an Australian student. Though Cato and Rosenbaum again lunched together on Wednesday, Rosenbaum has said a plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the riots with a family oriented neighborhood festival is insensitive, though Cato says he's OK with it. (AP Photo/Beth A. Keiser, File)
FILE - In this Aug. 21, 1991 file photo, New York City Police Department officers, in riot gear, walk past a police car that was overtuned by rioters in the Crown Heights section of the Brooklyn borough of New York. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/David Burns, File)
FILE - In this Aug. 21, 1991 file photo, New York City Police Department officers scuffle with a protester during a march through the Crown Heights section of the Brooklyn borough of New York. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/Joe Major, File)
FILE - In this Aug. 27, 1991 file photo, the casket of Gavin Cato passes the crowd of mourners outside St. Anthony's Baptist Church in the Brooklyn borough of New York. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/Joe Major, File)
FILE - In this Oct. 29, 1992, file photo, Norman Rosenbaum, center, brother of slain rabbinical student Yankel Rosenbaum, leaves state Supreme Court in the Brooklyn borough of New York, following the jury's verdict in the Crown Heights murder trail. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/Richard Harbus, File)
FILE - In this Aug. 21, 1991, file photo, the casket of Yankel Rosenbaum, a rabbinical student visiting from Australia, is carried through the streets of the Crown Heights section of the Brooklyn borough of New York. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/David Burns, File)
FILE - In this Aug. 21, 1991file photo, employees clean up a sneaker store that was vandalized during violence between residents and police in the Crown Heights section of the Brooklyn borough of New York. A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot with a family-friendly street festival has drawn criticism from the brother of a rabbinical student who suffered a fatal knife wound during the unrest. Organizers say the idea of the festival is to foster a sense of unity in the neighborhood. (AP Photo/Mario Cabrera, File)
FILE- In this Jan. 18, 1995 file photo, Devorah Halberstam, left, gestures as she and her husband, David Halberstam, meet with reporters outside the State Supreme Court in the Manhattan borough of New York. Devorah Halberstam is among the organizers of "One Crown Heights," a family oriented festival with games and rides taking place on the Crown Heights Riot's 25th anniversary. Their son, Ari Halberstam, was killed in a drive-by shooting on the Brooklyn Bridge in 1994. (AP Photo/David Karp, File)
FILE- In this April 28, 1994 file photo, Devorah Halberstam, mother of Ari Halberstam who was killed during a drive-by shooting on the Brooklyn Bridge, talks to reporters on the steps of City Hall in New York, as her husband David, left center, looks on. Devorah Halberstam is among the organizers of "One Crown Heights," a family oriented festival with games and rides taking place on the riot's 25th anniversary. Norman Rosenbaum, whose brother Yankel Rosenbaum was killed in the riots, objects to the event. "It's a trivialization of a very, very serious period of time, of a series of incidents culminating in my brother's murder," says Rosenbaum. (AP Photo/David Karp, File)

NEW YORK — It was the most searing racial clash in a generation in the nation's biggest city, spiraling out of the deaths of a black child and a Jewish doctoral student. Yet the 25th anniversary of the Crown Heights riot is being marked with games, rides and "fun for all ages."

It's meant to showcase unity in an area shaken by four days of violence in 1991. But the plan has opened a painful rift between the slain Jewish student's family and organizers, and it has raised questions about when celebration and commemoration can mix.

Promoted by a roster of elected officials, community groups and Jewish organizations, Sunday's "One Crown Heights" event starts with a commemoration ceremony. But the ensuing "neighborhood festival" galls relatives of Yankel Rosenbaum, who was stabbed to death as the riot began after a car in a prominent rabbi's motorcade fatally hit 7-year-old Gavin Cato.

"It's insensitive," said Rosenbaum's brother, Norman, who notes that the event's flier alludes to "the events of Aug. 20, 1991," not to rioting or deaths. "It's a trivialization of a very, very serious period of time, of a series of incidents culminating in my brother's murder."

His disapproval dismays one of the organizers, Devorah Halberstam, who stresses her empathy for the Rosenbaums. Her 16-year-old son, Ari, was killed on the Brooklyn Bridge in 1994 in a shooting aimed at a vanload of Jewish students.

"My total intention in this was to do right by Yankel and Gavin Cato" and show their families the community remembered and cared about them, said Halberstam, who helped establish the neighborhood's Jewish Children's Museum. To her, bringing children of different backgrounds together to have fun is a positive, forward-looking way to observe the anniversary and years of efforts to create more cohesion in Brooklyn's Crown Heights.

Ultra-Orthodox Hasidic Lubavitch Jews, African-Americans and black Caribbean immigrants had long been neighbors there when a car in the entourage of the Lubavitchers' spiritual leader, Rabbi Menachem Schneerson, jumped a curb and hit Gavin. Three hours later, black people shouting, "Get the Jew!" fatally stabbed Yankel Rosenbaum, 29, an Australian Jewish scholar who was in New York doing research.

Days of rioting by black Crown Heights residents followed in what a 1993 state report called "the most extensive racial unrest in New York City in over 20 years." Nearly 200 people were injured.

Now, Crown Heights is a gentrifying area where rising housing costs and an influx of newcomers stir some gripes of their own. But since the riot, residents have worked to foster communication and familiarity between blacks and Jews, from forming organizations together to speaking up when violence strikes either community.

Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams, a black former police officer, feels the atmosphere in Crown Heights has changed since the riot, and so should the commemoration.

"We should not spend our lives doing solemn ceremonies over and over again and not recognizing things that we should celebrate," he said.

The Anti-Defamation League, a group that fights anti-Semitism and bigotry, agrees there's room for "both commemorative and celebratory components." So does Gavin's father.

"I have no problem with that," said Carmel Cato.

But Rosenbaum's family isn't alone in condemning the event's tone.

"You can't have a fun festival commemorating a tragic event," and there are other days to celebrate unity, says Rabbi Yaacov Behrman, who runs a drug-prevention program and serves on a community board in Crown Heights. Isaac Abraham, who lives elsewhere in Brooklyn and has advocated for the Rosenbaum family for years, calls the festival "an insult and an embarrassment."

There have been disagreements before over whether solemn anniversaries can include festive notes. During a 2010 commemoration of the 45th anniversary of the Voting Rights Act, a group of young people angered the mayor of Selma, Alabama, by dancing on the bridge where a bloody confrontation between police and peaceful protesters helped spur the legislation.

Back in Crown Heights, Carmel Cato and Norman Rosenbaum have developed their own way of commemorating the riot. They got together in New York this week, as they have periodically since the 10th anniversary.

"Two families that suffered losses of loved ones in a terrible situation have come together" and hope others can do the same, Rosenbaum said.

"We might be different, but we're one people."

___

Reach Jennifer Peltz on Twitter @ jennpeltz.

People also read these

2 injured, fire contained on docked Tahoe paddle...

Aug 17, 2016

Fire ripped through the second deck of a docked tourist cruise boat under repair at Lake Tahoe on...

Hawaii authorities urge awareness of raw food risk

Aug 17, 2016

Hawaii authorities are urging diners to be aware of the risks of eating raw and undercooked food...

A festival to remember a riot? New York event...

Aug 18, 2016

A plan to mark the 25th anniversary of one of New York City's most searing race riots with a family...

NBA chooses New Orleans for 2017 All-Star Game

Aug 19, 2016

The NBA has decided to hold the 2017 All-Star Game in New Orleans after taking the midseason event...

24-hour subways signal new era for London, night...

Aug 19, 2016

The London Underground is introducing limited overnight service, a move city leaders hope will make...

Sign up now!

About Us

In The Headline sought to bring professionalism back into journalism, bringing you only the most exclusive and the most impactive news from all over the globe.

Contact us: sales[at]intheheadline.com